In Pedersen v. Forget (2026) ONCA 186, The Ontario Court of Appeal had a few things to saw regarding the treatment of liability expert opinions in the course of a slip and fall trial, and the weight given to these opinions, making this case is worth a read for members of the negligence bar, and their insurer clients.
In this case, the Plaintiff was an insurance adjuster who attended at the home of an insured, the Defendants, to obtain a statement regarding a prior claim. In a stroke of extreme irony, the Plaintiff slipped and fell on the stairs of the Defendants’ home, and commenced suit against them, pursuant to the Occupier’s Liability Act. The Plaintiff claims that right after she fell, she overheard one Defendant say to the other immediately after the fall, in French, that the house cleaner had used Pledge furniture polish to clear the stairs a couple of days prior.
The theory of liability advanced by the Plaintiff was that the staircase was extremely slippery, as a result of the housecleaner apparently using Pledge to clean it. The Defendants’ evidence at trial was that they did not have a housekeeper, and used Vim to clean the stairs, but never Pledge. The Plaintiff retained a forensic engineer who is better known for MVA accident reconstructions as a liability expert. The Defendant’s expert was a human factors specialist, which is a far more suitable expert for this kind of case.
The Plaintiff delivered multiple expert reports prior to trial. In his first report, in a masterpiece of questionable scientific methodology, the Plaintiff’s expert had used the landing at the stairs in his own home for slip testing, using, amongst other things, two different kinds of Pledge, and Vim. In his second report, he did the same at the Defendant’s home, accompanied by the Defendant’s expert, who did similar testing of his own. Apparently the test using one of the Pledge products at the Plaintiff’s house yielded some “unusual results” whereby the floor was actually less slippery, so this expert did further testing at his own house, which begat a third report.
There was a voir dire at trial regarding the Plaintiff’s expert’s anticipated testimony, which dealt with both his qualifications to give expert evidence, and with respect to various alleged flaws in the testing he did at his own house for his initial report. At the conclusion of this voir dire, the trial judge concluded that the Plaintiff’s expert was qualified to give opinion evidence, but that the results of the testing in the first report were not reliable for a variety of technical reasons (for example, he tested the coefficient of friction on the stairs just 20 minutes, not 2 days, after spraying Pledge on the stairs, and did not use a ladies dress sock or stocking at this time, such that this testing was considered “apples vs. oranges”). At the conclusion of the trial, jury found in favour of the Defendants, dismissing the Plaintiff’s claim.
The Plaintiff appealed on the basis that the trial judge erred in not permitting the evidence from the first report to go before the jury, and sought a new trial. The Plaintiff, in the course of the appeal, specifically suggested that the defendants might have tampered with the stairs before the testing at their house, because the use of one of the pledge products made the floor less slippery, which was not what the Plaintiff’s expert anticipated would happen, such that the testing he initially did at his own home was necessary to underpin this argument.
Wilson J, writing for the court, felt that there was no appealable error and that the verdict should stand. She concluded that the issue of tampering was a factual issue, and as such was the domain of the trier of fact, stating “it is not the role of this Court to re-weigh evidence”.
Wilson J then went on to conclude that even if she was mistaken about this, and the initial Plaintiff report was improperly excluded, there was no miscarriage of justice and no need for a new trial, as in the context of the entire record, it did not make a difference to the outcome of the trial. Specifically, the Defendants’ evidence about the cleaning of the stairs with Vim before the accident was also a credibility issue which the trial judge was entitled to make. Once this was concluded, any evidence on the slipperiness of Pledge and the potential issue of tampering was or was moot, particularly given that there was other evidence that the stairs were not slippery at the time, including that the Plaintiff ascended the stairs prior to her fall on the way down and had no issue with traction.
Takeaways from this case are as follows:
- Don’t polish your stairs if you have an adjuster coming over to take a statement;
- Be very, very circumspect if alleging expert shenanigans, improper conduct and/or “tampering”;
- Expert opinions don’t win cases. Facts do;
- When instructing and retaining experts, review their proposed methodology with a critical eye












