Civil proceedings sometimes follow criminal proceedings. When that occurs, it may be tempting to rely on the finding and decision from the earlier proceeding as trial-proof. But don’t be so hasty – two issues may arise as to (1) the legal effect of the criminal verdict, and (2) the scope of the evidence admissible in the subsequent civil action. The answers, as this article will demonstrate below, are not always intuitive.
Criminal Verdict in Subsequent Civil Proceedings
In Ontario, S. 22.1(1) of the Evidence Act provides that a criminal conviction gives rise to a legal presumption of wrongdoing which, unless rebutted with evidence, is binding in a subsequent civil suit.[1] That does not mean, however, that a civil defendant is free to retry the criminal case in attempting to rebut the presumption.
Specifically, the doctrine of abuse of process limits attempts to relitigate matters already decided. The doctrine imposes a high threshold for a Defendant who wishes to preclude a Plaintiff’s reliance on their prior conviction. In general, a party seeking to rebut the presumption of wrongdoing must establish one of the following:
- that the original proceeding was tainted by fraud or dishonesty;
- that fresh evidence, not previously available, conclusively impeaches the prior result;
- that the issues in the two proceedings are materially different; or
- that it would be unfair to give the prior result conclusive effect in the civil action.[2]
Although the fourth “fairness” factor is framed as a “catch-all”, it has been invoked in limited cases where, for example, there was inadequate incentive to defend in the prior proceeding but there is a higher burden of liability in the civil action.[3]
Even where the defendant has failed to rebut the presumption of wrongdoing, a conviction may not be adopted wholesale in establishing civil liability. Importantly, challenging the scope of the transcript to be admitted, for the purpose of avoiding drawing improper inferences from a prior finding, does not itself amount to an abuse of process.[4]
Thomas provides a useful example. In that case, the defendant pled guilty to impaired driving based on conduct that occurred approximately three hours after a hit-and-run collision.[5] The plaintiffs in the civil suit, alleged injured in the hit-and-run collision, sought to rely on that plea to argue that the defendant had also been impaired at the time of the collision. The Saskatchewan Court of Appeal rejected this argument, holding that the defendant was not appealing his conviction but merely resisting an overly broad interpretation of its scope.
Acquittals present the reverse problem. A criminal acquittal does not prove innocence; it establishes only that the prosecution failed to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. A later finding of civil liability, made on the balance of probabilities, is therefore not inherently inconsistent with the criminal result. The best, and most notorious example of this that comes to mind is, of course, OJ Simpson being acquitted of murder but found civilly liable to the Goldman and Brown families for the wrongful deals of Nicole Simpson and Ron Goldman.
This remains true even where the criminal trial judge provides reasons that go beyond the minimum necessary to acquit. In Polgrain, the trial judge went so far as to state that the alleged assault had never occurred.[6] Even so, the Ontario Court of Appeal held that such reasons could not be relied upon to bar a civil claim arising from the same facts because it is the verdict, not the reasons, that carries legal effect in this context. As such, courts will not allow a civil proceeding to be estopped simply because the reasoning behind a criminal acquittal appears to contradict it.
Criminal Transcripts in a Subsequent Civil Proceeding
Even where abuse of process fails to bar a civil Plaintiff relying on a prior criminal finding, the transcript from that proceeding must still satisfies the ordinary rules of evidence. As such, the first question to ask is whether the transcript is admitted for its truth – if not, the hearsay rule does not apply at all.[7]
It is advisable that counsels give careful thought to why the transcript is needed to go into evidence, as statements offered not for their truth may be admissible for limited purposes. In Belong, the court admitted the criminal transcript in a civil suit against the RCMP, not to prove the underlying criminal allegations, but to assess whether the internal disciplinary investigation had acted reasonably in light of the information then available.[8] Prior transcripts may also be used to impeach a witness’s credibility where the witness has made inconsistent statements in the subsequent proceeding.[9]
The issue becomes more difficult where a transcript is offered for its truth. Unless a traditional hearsay exception applies, the party relying on the transcript would have to rely on the common law “principled approach”, whereby hearsay evidence may be admitted if it satisfies the twin criteria of (1) necessity, and (2) reliability.[10]
Necessity is interpreted broadly and does not require the declarant to be absolutely unavailable to testify.[11] Reliability focuses on the “particular dangers raised by the hearsay evidence sought to be introduced” and “the attributes or circumstances relied upon by the proponent to overcome those dangers”.[12] In Clayson-Martin, while the expert testimony had been given under oath in the earlier proceeding, the court noted that the danger was not that the expert might lie, but that she might have been mistaken, particularly because she had not been cross-examined by the adverse party in the civil proceeding.[13]
Conclusion
Prior criminal proceedings can be powerful tools in subsequent civil litigation, but they should not be treated as convenient shortcuts. Counsels should be aware of the scope of admissibility for transcripts and the circumstances in which transcripts of prior proceedings can be admitted into evidence. Often, it is a matter of simply going back to “first principles” – in particular the hearsay rule. Counsel seeking to rely on a prior criminal transcript in a civil matter would be well advised to re-familiarize themselves with the hearsay rule and the “principled” approach to hearsay exceptions.
[1] Evidence Act, RSO 1990, c E.23, s 22.1. See also Lerners LLP, “Criminal v. Civil: Criminal Process Can Impact Parallel Civil Process”, online: https://lerners.ca/lernx/criminal-v-civil-criminal-process-can-impact-parallel-civil-process.
[2] Toronto (City) v Canadian Union of Public Employees (CUPE), Local 79, 2003 SCC 63; Hanna and Hanna, personally, by their Litigation Guardian Douglas Hanna v Abbott [Indexed as: Hanna v Abbott], 82 OR (3d) 215.
[3] Toronto (City) v Canadian Union of Public Employees (CUPE), Local 79, 2003 SCC 63, citing Danyluk v Ainsworth Technologies Inc, 2001 SCC 44 at para 51 and KF v White, [2001] OJ No 847 at para 55.
[4] Thomas v Quinlan, 2020 SKCA 82 (Thomas).
[5] Thomas v Quinlan, 2020 SKCA 82 (Thomas).
[6] Polgrain as Executor on behalf of Polgrain v Toronto East General Hospital et al [Indexed as: Polgrain Estate v Toronto East General Hospital], 90 OR (3d) 630 (Polgrain).
[7] D M Paciocco, P Paciocco & L Stuesser, The Law of Evidence, 8th ed (Toronto: Irwin Law, 2020) at 135.
[8] Belong v Canada (Attorney General), 2013 NBCA 68 (Belong).
[9] D M Paciocco, P Paciocco & L Stuesser, The Law of Evidence, 8th ed (Toronto: Irwin Law, 2020) at 608.
[10] Clayson-Martin v Martin, 2015 ONCA 596, citing R v Khelawon, 2006 SCC 57 at para 77. See also R v Khan, [1990] 2 SCR 531.
[11] R v Khelawon, 2006 SCC 57 at para 78.
[12] R v Khelawon, 2006 SCC 57 at para 93.












