The courts recently revisited the issues of voluntary assumption of risk and waivers in the context of recreational activities in the recent case of Kolsen v. New Tecumseth (Town) (2026) ONSC 2729 which was heard before the Honourable Mr. Justice Edwards in September 2025.
In this case, the Plaintiff was a member of a Slo-Pitch baseball league, who sustained a facial injury while trying to catch a ball at a night game in May 2019 at first base. He gave evidence that as he was lining up to catch the ball, which was thrown to him by the second baseman, he was blinded by the field’s lighting, which he described as appearing like a “bright white flash”. It appears that the Plaintiff’s theory of liability was that the floodlights at this field were aligned and configured in such a way that they could potentially interfere with fielders’ ability to see balls, and that this constituted a breach of the applicable standard of care.
Upon joining this league for the season, as he had done every year since 2012, the Plaintiff signed an on-line waiver as part of the registration process. The waiver related to “tournaments” rather than regular league games. The game at which the Plaintiff was injured was a league game, and the Plaintiff took the position that the waiver did not apply as it only applied to tournament play. It is noteworthy that in 2023, the wording of the waiver was revised so that, amongst other things, it referred to “league play” as well as tournaments.
Edwards J commenced his analysis of whether the waiver should be enforced by going through the prior jurisprudence on waivers. In so doing, he noted the following key points:
- If a Defendant seeks to rely on a waiver, then the onus rests upon them to prove that its wording applies to exclude the Plaintiff’s claim;
- Waivers are to be interpreted narrowly, based on their precise wording, and any ambiguity in the waiver will be interpreted in the most advantageous manner to the Plaintiff;
- If a Defendant wants to exclude claims for negligence through the waiver, then it must do so by way of the clearest of language;
- The Defendant must take reasonable steps, when relying on a waiver, to bring the language of the waiver to the attention of the participants in the activity in question.
In this case, Edwards J. found that the waiver in question did not make any mention of the statutory duty of care imposed by the Occupier’s Liability Act[1], or to exclude or limit liability arising from a breach of this duty, and went on to state “if the statutory duty of care is not brought to the attention of the Plaintiff, it is difficult to see how a waiver can exclude a liability of which the Plaintiff has not been made aware”. He noted that as of 2023 in addition to being changed to include league play, the waiver was also amended to exclude liability based on “the breach of any statutory duty of care”.
Edwards J did conclude, however, that the Plaintiff should have known what this waiver said, despite his evidence at trial that he only “glanced” at it, stating that having signed the waiver on-line as part of the league registration process every year since 2012, he had “every opportunity” to review the contents of the waiver before clicking on the “agree” box. His Honour also concluded that had the Plaintiff read the waiver, he would have known that there was a risk of injury from the game of baseball which is, in and of itself, potentially dangerous. He stated, however, that as this waiver only applied, based on its language, to “tournament” games, that it did not, as a matter of law, apply to the regular league game in which the Plaintiff was injured. Edwards J’s rationale in coming to what some may think a somewhat unreasonable and overly technical conclusion was that it was up to the Defendant baseball league to choose what language it wished to use in the waiver, and that it cannot retroactively be re-written to cover a loss that was not originally covered by its express language. As such, Edwards J concluded that the waiver did not protect the Plaintiff in this case, as the injury did not occur during tournament play.
However, this all turned out to be a pyrrhic victory for the Plaintiff, as Edwards J went on to consider whether there was actually a breach of the standard of care on the Defendants’ part in this case. He noted that the Defendants are not, based on the wording of the Occupiers’ Liability Act, “insurers” for anyone who chooses to play slo-pitch baseball and is injured in the process, and do not bear the responsibility to guarantee the safety of the players in their league from “any conceivable hazard”. Instead, it is up to the Plaintiff to marshal the evidence necessary to establish that the Defendant failed to act reasonably. He concluded, on the basis of the evidence before the court, that the only way to adjust the lighting at this field was by bringing heavy equipment (presumably a scissor lift or bucket lift truck) onto the field to allow workers to access the lights. As of May 2022, the ground was still not firm enough following the winter for heavy equipment to be brought on the field. Therefore, he concluded that given the Plaintiff was aware of this sort of hazard, generally speaking, and that there was a viable reason why the lighting had not been aligned or adjusted for this early-season game, that there was no breach of the duty of reasonableness imposed by the Occupier’s Liability Act.
Also, astoundingly, the Plaintiffs did not call any expert evidence at trial as to what might constitute reasonableness in the context of making sure baseball diamond lighting was appropriate and safe. As such, without any evidence of what the applicable standard care might be, Edwards J was not in a position to determine whether the state of the lighting on the occasion in question was in breach of this standard. As a result of this, despite the Defendants’ waiver not being enforced, the Plaintiff’s claim was dismissed.
So what are the takeaways?
- From the perspective of a Defendant, if you wish to rely on a waiver to protect you from liability in relation to a recreational activity, you had best make certain that the waiver is properly worded and reflects the risks inherent in the particular activity you are responsible for. If you have a waiver which you “cut and paste” from another event, you used AI to draft, or which you simply have not reviewed in a while, step away from your computer right now, pull that waiver out and read it very, very closely to make sure it expressly excludes the risks inherent in whatever activity you are running;
- Also from the perspective of a Defendant, the manner in which the waiver is presented to participants is just as important as what it says. In the author’s view, the best practice in this regard is to have an on-line waiver which participants sign as part of the on-line registration process, and which they can click through at their own leisure. Conversely, handing someone a page with a sea of fine print when they arrive the morning of the event and having them sign it is less than ideal.
- And for Plaintiffs, do not lose sight of the forest for the trees. What caused your client’s injury Can it be traced to something the Defendant could have done better? What is the “industry standard”, how did the Defendant’s conduct deviate from it and what evidence can you call to support this? If you cannot answer these questions at an early stage of the litigation, it might be time for a serious discussion with your client.
[1] This statute, as a general proposition, places anyone in possession or control of a particular premises under the obligation to take reasonable steps to keep people on the premises reasonably safe from reasonably foreseeable harm












